Not really- he's calling us a bunch of twelve year olds
Are you a 12 year old? Otherwise I do not see how being called a 12 year old has any negative effects on you personally.
If someone calls you a fool and you aren't, then you truly are a fool if you get mad at it.
If he's never on the server, why should it matter to him? It shouldn't.
If you had never even seen this seal, why should it matter to you if I were to mercilessly club it?
Just because of "never being here on the server" doesn't justify a banishment in its own right.
Although it may not be the right thing to do, it shouldn't bother him if we do ban him.
Well that's specifically the reason why.
Why should we have to do something not necessarily right in order to ban someone?
This isn't some sort of Al Capone situation where since we couldn't find him "trolling" we'd might as well get him on the fact that he doesn't capitalize the first letter in his name.
allllllmost though